My son is 23 he has a Masters degree in Economics and finance he left university and applied for 400+ jobs, he got nothing back, nada, zilch. His CV was checked by a professional HR person we know and was in good order.
He first got a casual job delivering parcels and in April this year landed a local job as a trainee service manager.
It's a small family run firm but its work is nationwide and he has flourished, he's not a number. He has earnt his bosses respect.
His fiancée moved up she has a Masters degree and she has landed a job working in a pub. She has an interview tomorrow for a position in sales, its a job she really wants in a field she loves, so we've all got our fingers crossed.
Job hunting isn't easy, getting past the AI application sift seems to be nigh on impossible.
My son was given a chance, which he grabbed with both hands and ran with it.
Bosses give these young people a chance, you may pleasantly surprised.
I only started getting interview offers when I took my masters off my CV. And then when I got an interview, very often, 'We cannot match your existing salary'.
Well, I didn't ask you to match it. I was moving from teaching and wanted to work in sustainability and was explicitly applying for entry level jobs but the automated screening was killing me!
Just read my damn CV and very specifically tailored cover letter that explains why I was applying for jobs with a £15,000 drop in salary
All these connived, confusing and downright inhuman policies are based on one requirement. To other then do harm to specific groups of human beings.
The moral panic is just a means of justifying the visceral desire to hurt people who belong to one group or another that is the subject of common or garden prejudice.
The likes of Mahmood and Milburn are ruthlessly exploiting the trend to secure power for the longer term and fuck the consequences to individuals and society.
I would add the Telegraph to the list of scaremongering media. Their reporting is very misleading and I continue to be astounded at the callousness and sheer viciousness of the comments people make. I've stopped looking now, I can't bear it.
The other thing that is often forgotten is that we have more people than ever claiming benefit who are actually working. So the welfare state is NOT propping up 'the lazy and feckless' it is propping up business and organisations who are not being made to pay sufficient salaries that enable people to live without being 'topped up' - I don't have the data to hand but I'm sure you have it Bear :-)
How right you are Bear. Scapegoating has become the norm in politics now, let’s target the most vulnerable, the youngsters, the sick, the disabled. Such easy pickings.
It sickens me, some of the comments seen on social media are shocking, from those who have little or no understanding of the subject discussed. It’s bear a baiting (sorry Bear) Social media has a lot to answer for.
I'm on benefits due to long term health issues. My daughter, luckily who won't be affected by the draconian measures suggested, is also on benefits due to long term health issues. More and more people are working and claiming PIP. Surely the correct way forward would be to tax billionaires and companies. Why take it out on children? Why should they suffer?
I also like the way the government continually push up the retirement age, whilst the number of actual jobs appears to be falling as AI takes over in places like call centres and the like, and then bemoans youngsters not having a job and sponging off the state. Politicians (or the civil servants who guide them) have no clue of what faces the person on the street.
Yep. All those stepping stone jobs being automated and then businesses complaining that they either can't fill middle leadership roles that require expertise or need those already in those middle roles to work even harder and then burnout and leave.
Young people are the country's most important natural resource, and the job of a responsible government is to invest seriously in their future. Because their futures are our futures. Anything less is criminally negligent.
And on the subject of Xitter, it was really strange how almost all of the weird accounts posting and amplifying toxic shit suddenly disappeared when the Ukrainians smashed one of Russia's biggest data centres. 🤔
If social media opinion was a genuine reflection of public opinion, it would deserve a seat at the. deciding table, but of course it's anything but an accurate reflection.
First off, take X and the blue tick which enables users to pay to have their opinions and those of their followers appear more important than the rest of us.
Secondly, as any fule kno, people use social media to sound off about issues, adding their enraged, intemperate, fury of the moment emotionalism into the mix. Ten minutes later, they feel better for getting that off their chest, but rarely post to that effect .
Not to mention the mystery of the algorithm, which bends and sways with a wind that none of us really understand but which includes bias, monetisation, and is actually, factually mindless.
Not so much a case of the lunatics running the asylum (sorry lunatics) but of the chief pychiatrists personal and disturbing dream diary taking the reins.
As ever 🐻, you get to the heart of the issue and explain it so clearly. Andy Burnham’s Labour Party are aligning themselves far too closely with Farage and the far right. If the mainstream media would do their jobs and report facts instead of continually showcasing Farage and his lies, then maybe this country could get past the hatred and division. Andy Burnham needs to start using the facts to influence policy decisions, but sadly I don’t see that happening any time soon!
As the parent of a 21 year old who will almost certainly never be well enough to be able to join the workforce, I appalled terrified and incandescent with rage, not only at the apparent contents of the report, but also at the way its low-lights have been released before parliament has even seen the document.
My dear one began to struggle with their mental health at 15. Their GP felt that anti depressants were needed, but these she could not legally prescribe. She wrote an emergency referral to CAMHS in January 2020. School backed this up with their own referral. We now had to wait. The screening appointment took place in April, and CAMHS agreed to take on the case. Their first actual appoint took place on line in late July. By August, they suspected Autism. In late September, they confirmed it. I was sent a link to a Temple Grandin video ( spoiler: not cutting edge information. Ms Grandin is autistic but struggles with internalised ableism) and left to get on with it. But what about the depression? Weren't they going to prescribe anti depressants? Good lord, no! That would be heavy handed at this stage. In October, I insisted they look at anti depressants, because talking therapies were not working. It wasn't until December that we finally spoke to a CAMHS doctor and treatment started. Almost a full year since we saw the GP. The damage was immense. My child never returned to full time education and left school at 16 with very few qualifications. They experienced autistic burnout. CAMHS did not know such a thing existed. Six years down the line, due to co-occurring conditions, my young person has some serious physical disabilities to go along with the autism, and the ADHD they wouldn't refer for diagnosis.(Apparently, it's considered greedy to have both). We went through the heart breaking and degrading process of applying for PIP, and were awarded higher level for care and mobility, based on their high care needs. Now it appears that everyone between 18 and 25 won't be eligible for PIP, being miraculously cured of whatever was causing them to need care in the first place. (Do they relapse at 26?). And no PIP means no Carer's Allowance. That's a hit to the already tight household budget of around £1,000 a month. But no worries - the pain isn't falling on the report's author. Just a young disabled adult, their mother who can only work part time around care responsibility, and their father forced to retire early due to chronic back issues and live off savings for three years until he finally gets his pension. Nobody important. And at least we won't be alone.
Great piece Bear. I didn't vote for algorithms or AI to take over human activities either! Too much robot, not enough human in all areas of politics, not just social media 🙄 The young are facing a battle I never had to face when applying to work. It saddens and maddens me that companies just keep implementing AI without proper consideration and protection of humans. It's no wonder there is a mental health crisis - and no solutions except cut the benefits. Appalling! Labour need to stop, rethink and review what they are doing. Go after the corporations and banks, leave the young alone!
One thing that needs to be remembered when it comes to the problems young people are facing with mental health challenges is that the scientists and politicians making decisions during the time of COVID literally shrugged their shoulders and said "they're resilient, they'll bounce back."
Really? They'll bounce back from a national trauma that has no precedent? The closes equivalent is the Blitz, and even then it doesn't equate.
That might sound callous until you consider that the Blitz centred on key metropolitan sites and military installations. Covid was everywhere. Kids could escape to the country during the Blitz.
During Covid, some of them couldn't even leave their homes. When you figure for those poor tykes that were locked in with raging psychopaths that are into domestic abuse, well, they might have been better off in the East of London next door to a munitions factory, and a damn sight safer.
We effectively ran a national experiment in the effectiveness of child development and family support during the epidemic. Guess what? It turns out that a lot of those theories were bang on the money. A lot of those services were actually good value for money. Just like the SureStart services Cameron decided we could do with back in 2010.
Sunak decided that all we needed to do was bung a few hundred grand to a few Tory chums to run electronic tutoring services for GCSE and that would sort things out. That £15bn his Covid Recovery Czar said was needed, but that he decided we could do without. Guess what? That is another one of his f*** ups.
That, of course, is just considering one side of the coin. Another side is the employment market, or rather, the unemployment market. Stories here already about the sheer number of people with kids who have graduated with good, valued degrees, who are struggling to get shelf-stacking jobs in a local supermarket are commonplace.
On the other side of that little problem, employers recruiting for decent paying jobs are inundated with applications. We're talking in the hundreds for a job that might have once struggled to attract a dozen. It's still no excuse for not providing any response. In this day and age, a fairly simple mailmerge (okay, maybe not with Microsoft ...) could manage that. Hell, they could employ one of the applicants to run it for them, I'm sure.
As challenging as this is, I have to be honest. My total, unequivocal, unremitting, absolute, complete and utter contempt is reserved for the Conservative governments of the last decade or so. Running down the NHS and leaving the nation so vulnerable to start with. The cavalier attitude to preparedness and early signs. The disregard for anything other than the financial costs to business. The parsimonious approach to support for the vulnerable ... the list just goes on and on.
And yes, those on the SAGE committee who treated our children with such contempt should also answer for their decisions. Not one of them was qualified to answer questions on anything other than the epidemiological implications of COVID. Then again, they did get their just desserts: Johnson and his ilk threw them under the bus the first chance they got.
I know this rant is a bit of a tangent to the core topic of social media but at the same time I feel like it is something that has been allowed to sink below the radar. It shouldn't. Any time any politician (especialy Tory politicians, and I'm including the ones that have sloped off to Reform here, too) wants to harp on about young people's mental health and the cost to the taxpayer, we need to remind them of the reasons WHY we are facing these difficulties.
As the parent of a 21 year old who will almost certainly never be well enough to be able to join the workforce, I appalled terrified and incandescent with rage, not only at the apparent contents of the report, but also at the way its low-lights have been released before parliament has even seen the document.
My dear one began to struggle with their mental health at 15. Their GP felt that anti depressants were needed, but these she could not legally prescribe. She wrote an emergency referral to CAMHS in January 2020. School backed this up with their own referral. We now had to wait. The screening appointment took place in April, and CAMHS agreed to take on the case. Their first actual appoint took place on line in late July. By August, they suspected Autism. In late September, they confirmed it. I was sent a link to a Temple Grandin video ( spoiler: not cutting edge information. Ms Grandin is autistic but struggles with internalised ableism) and left to get on with it. But what about the depression? Weren't they going to prescribe anti depressants? Good lord, no! That would be heavy handed at this stage. In October, I insisted they look at anti depressants, because talking therapies were not working. It wasn't until December that we finally spoke to a CAMHS doctor and treatment started. Almost a full year since we saw the GP. The damage was immense. My child never returned to full time education and left school at 16 with very few qualifications. They experienced autistic burnout. CAMHS did not know such a thing existed. Six years down the line, due to co-occurring conditions, my young person has some serious physical disabilities to go along with the autism, and the ADHD they wouldn't refer for diagnosis.(Apparently, it's considered greedy to have both). We went through the heart breaking and degrading process of applying for PIP, and were awarded higher level for care and mobility, based on their high care needs. Now it appears that everyone between 18 and 25 won't be eligible for PIP, being miraculously cured of whatever was causing them to need care in the first place. (Do they relapse at 26?). And no PIP means no Carer's Allowance. That's a hit to the already tight household budget of around £1,000 a month. But no worries - the pain isn't falling on the report's author. Just a young disabled adult, their mother who can only work part time around care responsibility, and their father forced to retire early due to chronic back issues and live off savings for three years until he finally gets his pension. Nobody important. And at least we won't be alone.
My son is 23 he has a Masters degree in Economics and finance he left university and applied for 400+ jobs, he got nothing back, nada, zilch. His CV was checked by a professional HR person we know and was in good order.
He first got a casual job delivering parcels and in April this year landed a local job as a trainee service manager.
It's a small family run firm but its work is nationwide and he has flourished, he's not a number. He has earnt his bosses respect.
His fiancée moved up she has a Masters degree and she has landed a job working in a pub. She has an interview tomorrow for a position in sales, its a job she really wants in a field she loves, so we've all got our fingers crossed.
Job hunting isn't easy, getting past the AI application sift seems to be nigh on impossible.
My son was given a chance, which he grabbed with both hands and ran with it.
Bosses give these young people a chance, you may pleasantly surprised.
I only started getting interview offers when I took my masters off my CV. And then when I got an interview, very often, 'We cannot match your existing salary'.
Well, I didn't ask you to match it. I was moving from teaching and wanted to work in sustainability and was explicitly applying for entry level jobs but the automated screening was killing me!
Just read my damn CV and very specifically tailored cover letter that explains why I was applying for jobs with a £15,000 drop in salary
Morning Bear.
All these connived, confusing and downright inhuman policies are based on one requirement. To other then do harm to specific groups of human beings.
The moral panic is just a means of justifying the visceral desire to hurt people who belong to one group or another that is the subject of common or garden prejudice.
The likes of Mahmood and Milburn are ruthlessly exploiting the trend to secure power for the longer term and fuck the consequences to individuals and society.
I would add the Telegraph to the list of scaremongering media. Their reporting is very misleading and I continue to be astounded at the callousness and sheer viciousness of the comments people make. I've stopped looking now, I can't bear it.
The other thing that is often forgotten is that we have more people than ever claiming benefit who are actually working. So the welfare state is NOT propping up 'the lazy and feckless' it is propping up business and organisations who are not being made to pay sufficient salaries that enable people to live without being 'topped up' - I don't have the data to hand but I'm sure you have it Bear :-)
How right you are Bear. Scapegoating has become the norm in politics now, let’s target the most vulnerable, the youngsters, the sick, the disabled. Such easy pickings.
It sickens me, some of the comments seen on social media are shocking, from those who have little or no understanding of the subject discussed. It’s bear a baiting (sorry Bear) Social media has a lot to answer for.
I don’t know where you find the time, but thank you so much for doing so.
I'm on benefits due to long term health issues. My daughter, luckily who won't be affected by the draconian measures suggested, is also on benefits due to long term health issues. More and more people are working and claiming PIP. Surely the correct way forward would be to tax billionaires and companies. Why take it out on children? Why should they suffer?
Cheers Bear, hit the nail on the head as ever.
My thought is the people who are working and getting UC. That’s just subsidising the big corporations isn’t it?
I also like the way the government continually push up the retirement age, whilst the number of actual jobs appears to be falling as AI takes over in places like call centres and the like, and then bemoans youngsters not having a job and sponging off the state. Politicians (or the civil servants who guide them) have no clue of what faces the person on the street.
Great post as always Bear.
Yep. All those stepping stone jobs being automated and then businesses complaining that they either can't fill middle leadership roles that require expertise or need those already in those middle roles to work even harder and then burnout and leave.
Very well put, Bear. As always, you’ve got your finger firmly on the pulse, if you’ll pardon the medical analogy\! 😉
Young people are the country's most important natural resource, and the job of a responsible government is to invest seriously in their future. Because their futures are our futures. Anything less is criminally negligent.
And on the subject of Xitter, it was really strange how almost all of the weird accounts posting and amplifying toxic shit suddenly disappeared when the Ukrainians smashed one of Russia's biggest data centres. 🤔
If social media opinion was a genuine reflection of public opinion, it would deserve a seat at the. deciding table, but of course it's anything but an accurate reflection.
First off, take X and the blue tick which enables users to pay to have their opinions and those of their followers appear more important than the rest of us.
Secondly, as any fule kno, people use social media to sound off about issues, adding their enraged, intemperate, fury of the moment emotionalism into the mix. Ten minutes later, they feel better for getting that off their chest, but rarely post to that effect .
Not to mention the mystery of the algorithm, which bends and sways with a wind that none of us really understand but which includes bias, monetisation, and is actually, factually mindless.
Not so much a case of the lunatics running the asylum (sorry lunatics) but of the chief pychiatrists personal and disturbing dream diary taking the reins.
As ever 🐻, you get to the heart of the issue and explain it so clearly. Andy Burnham’s Labour Party are aligning themselves far too closely with Farage and the far right. If the mainstream media would do their jobs and report facts instead of continually showcasing Farage and his lies, then maybe this country could get past the hatred and division. Andy Burnham needs to start using the facts to influence policy decisions, but sadly I don’t see that happening any time soon!
As the parent of a 21 year old who will almost certainly never be well enough to be able to join the workforce, I appalled terrified and incandescent with rage, not only at the apparent contents of the report, but also at the way its low-lights have been released before parliament has even seen the document.
My dear one began to struggle with their mental health at 15. Their GP felt that anti depressants were needed, but these she could not legally prescribe. She wrote an emergency referral to CAMHS in January 2020. School backed this up with their own referral. We now had to wait. The screening appointment took place in April, and CAMHS agreed to take on the case. Their first actual appoint took place on line in late July. By August, they suspected Autism. In late September, they confirmed it. I was sent a link to a Temple Grandin video ( spoiler: not cutting edge information. Ms Grandin is autistic but struggles with internalised ableism) and left to get on with it. But what about the depression? Weren't they going to prescribe anti depressants? Good lord, no! That would be heavy handed at this stage. In October, I insisted they look at anti depressants, because talking therapies were not working. It wasn't until December that we finally spoke to a CAMHS doctor and treatment started. Almost a full year since we saw the GP. The damage was immense. My child never returned to full time education and left school at 16 with very few qualifications. They experienced autistic burnout. CAMHS did not know such a thing existed. Six years down the line, due to co-occurring conditions, my young person has some serious physical disabilities to go along with the autism, and the ADHD they wouldn't refer for diagnosis.(Apparently, it's considered greedy to have both). We went through the heart breaking and degrading process of applying for PIP, and were awarded higher level for care and mobility, based on their high care needs. Now it appears that everyone between 18 and 25 won't be eligible for PIP, being miraculously cured of whatever was causing them to need care in the first place. (Do they relapse at 26?). And no PIP means no Carer's Allowance. That's a hit to the already tight household budget of around £1,000 a month. But no worries - the pain isn't falling on the report's author. Just a young disabled adult, their mother who can only work part time around care responsibility, and their father forced to retire early due to chronic back issues and live off savings for three years until he finally gets his pension. Nobody important. And at least we won't be alone.
Great piece Bear. I didn't vote for algorithms or AI to take over human activities either! Too much robot, not enough human in all areas of politics, not just social media 🙄 The young are facing a battle I never had to face when applying to work. It saddens and maddens me that companies just keep implementing AI without proper consideration and protection of humans. It's no wonder there is a mental health crisis - and no solutions except cut the benefits. Appalling! Labour need to stop, rethink and review what they are doing. Go after the corporations and banks, leave the young alone!
One thing that needs to be remembered when it comes to the problems young people are facing with mental health challenges is that the scientists and politicians making decisions during the time of COVID literally shrugged their shoulders and said "they're resilient, they'll bounce back."
Really? They'll bounce back from a national trauma that has no precedent? The closes equivalent is the Blitz, and even then it doesn't equate.
That might sound callous until you consider that the Blitz centred on key metropolitan sites and military installations. Covid was everywhere. Kids could escape to the country during the Blitz.
During Covid, some of them couldn't even leave their homes. When you figure for those poor tykes that were locked in with raging psychopaths that are into domestic abuse, well, they might have been better off in the East of London next door to a munitions factory, and a damn sight safer.
We effectively ran a national experiment in the effectiveness of child development and family support during the epidemic. Guess what? It turns out that a lot of those theories were bang on the money. A lot of those services were actually good value for money. Just like the SureStart services Cameron decided we could do with back in 2010.
Sunak decided that all we needed to do was bung a few hundred grand to a few Tory chums to run electronic tutoring services for GCSE and that would sort things out. That £15bn his Covid Recovery Czar said was needed, but that he decided we could do without. Guess what? That is another one of his f*** ups.
That, of course, is just considering one side of the coin. Another side is the employment market, or rather, the unemployment market. Stories here already about the sheer number of people with kids who have graduated with good, valued degrees, who are struggling to get shelf-stacking jobs in a local supermarket are commonplace.
On the other side of that little problem, employers recruiting for decent paying jobs are inundated with applications. We're talking in the hundreds for a job that might have once struggled to attract a dozen. It's still no excuse for not providing any response. In this day and age, a fairly simple mailmerge (okay, maybe not with Microsoft ...) could manage that. Hell, they could employ one of the applicants to run it for them, I'm sure.
As challenging as this is, I have to be honest. My total, unequivocal, unremitting, absolute, complete and utter contempt is reserved for the Conservative governments of the last decade or so. Running down the NHS and leaving the nation so vulnerable to start with. The cavalier attitude to preparedness and early signs. The disregard for anything other than the financial costs to business. The parsimonious approach to support for the vulnerable ... the list just goes on and on.
And yes, those on the SAGE committee who treated our children with such contempt should also answer for their decisions. Not one of them was qualified to answer questions on anything other than the epidemiological implications of COVID. Then again, they did get their just desserts: Johnson and his ilk threw them under the bus the first chance they got.
I know this rant is a bit of a tangent to the core topic of social media but at the same time I feel like it is something that has been allowed to sink below the radar. It shouldn't. Any time any politician (especialy Tory politicians, and I'm including the ones that have sloped off to Reform here, too) wants to harp on about young people's mental health and the cost to the taxpayer, we need to remind them of the reasons WHY we are facing these difficulties.
As the parent of a 21 year old who will almost certainly never be well enough to be able to join the workforce, I appalled terrified and incandescent with rage, not only at the apparent contents of the report, but also at the way its low-lights have been released before parliament has even seen the document.
My dear one began to struggle with their mental health at 15. Their GP felt that anti depressants were needed, but these she could not legally prescribe. She wrote an emergency referral to CAMHS in January 2020. School backed this up with their own referral. We now had to wait. The screening appointment took place in April, and CAMHS agreed to take on the case. Their first actual appoint took place on line in late July. By August, they suspected Autism. In late September, they confirmed it. I was sent a link to a Temple Grandin video ( spoiler: not cutting edge information. Ms Grandin is autistic but struggles with internalised ableism) and left to get on with it. But what about the depression? Weren't they going to prescribe anti depressants? Good lord, no! That would be heavy handed at this stage. In October, I insisted they look at anti depressants, because talking therapies were not working. It wasn't until December that we finally spoke to a CAMHS doctor and treatment started. Almost a full year since we saw the GP. The damage was immense. My child never returned to full time education and left school at 16 with very few qualifications. They experienced autistic burnout. CAMHS did not know such a thing existed. Six years down the line, due to co-occurring conditions, my young person has some serious physical disabilities to go along with the autism, and the ADHD they wouldn't refer for diagnosis.(Apparently, it's considered greedy to have both). We went through the heart breaking and degrading process of applying for PIP, and were awarded higher level for care and mobility, based on their high care needs. Now it appears that everyone between 18 and 25 won't be eligible for PIP, being miraculously cured of whatever was causing them to need care in the first place. (Do they relapse at 26?). And no PIP means no Carer's Allowance. That's a hit to the already tight household budget of around £1,000 a month. But no worries - the pain isn't falling on the report's author. Just a young disabled adult, their mother who can only work part time around care responsibility, and their father forced to retire early due to chronic back issues and live off savings for three years until he finally gets his pension. Nobody important. And at least we won't be alone.