8 Comments
User's avatar
Baz's avatar

This is from Robert Reich's Substack in June 2025:

Brotech

Draw a circle around all the assets in America now devoted to Artificial Intelligence.

Draw a second circle around all the assets devoted to the U.S. military.

A third around all assets being devoted to helping the Trump regime collect and compile personal information on millions of Americans.

And a fourth circle around the parts of Silicon Valley dedicated to turning the United States away from a democracy into a libertarian dictatorship led by tech bros.

Where do the four circles intersect?

At a corporation called Palantir Technologies and a man named Peter Thiel.

Dianne Beck's avatar

Keep asking the awkward questions everyone - with thanks.

Máire Nic Shéamais.'s avatar

I would love to see the Data Protection Impact Assessment that was done on this engagement (presumably). When I was a DPO, engaging any US based tech company was always a challenge if you wanted to show genuine compliance with GDPR* and using one as enmeshed in the US government in its present state as Palantir is must come with multiple risks which I would be interested to see how it was proposed would be overcome.

* there are solutions but they come at a cost which I am not sure the NHS could realistically afford to pay.

The other problem these days is that some privacy professionals/engineers will tell you that there is no longer any such thing as truly anonymised data, so letting any foreign tech business near this 'Crown Jewels' of a data store has to involve a lot of trust.

I just hope that this worst of the worst of US tech companies will eventually be shown the door.

DEREK HANDS's avatar

2 years too many

MsTKIndeed's avatar

It's amusing to me that Huawei IT contracts were immediately terminated by May's government citing concerns of Chinese involvement in UK government contracts, but that Palantir, arguably more dangerous in my opinion, get an extension to their NHS involvement to 2029. It took one project, paid for by Home Office, which had based it's architecture around Huawei products, about a year to retender, redesign and source new components so why does Palantir get to stay longer? Continuity of care should not be used as an excuse to keep them on board longer.

Rick Jones's avatar

Thanks for this. Now I finally properly understand the issues surrounding Palantir in the NHS. Nice to read something clear, factual, hype-free and from inside knowledge!

Baz's avatar
44mEdited

There is a weekly protest at Palantir’s UK HQ, gather at 4pm outside 20 Soho Square London every Thursday. Tell Tom Watson I sent you.

https://substack.com/@frequentquestionasker/note/p-206512428?utm_source=notes-share-action&r=qk6nn

Frances Carter's avatar

Thanks for the clarity on the Palantir issue 🐻. As a former government finance professional, all of the issues that started with covid and the awful financial decisions made by the Tories have concerned me. I knew that Palantir had some questionable areas, and I have signed petitions to get them out of the NHS, but you have once again given me the perspective to see why it’s so important. Thanks 🐻